What I Learned About Fixing Miscommunication and Meal Prep to Avoid Bad Ratings in Hospitality

A small detail's big impact: How minor missteps can turn guest satisfaction into disappointment. Photo by: Internet

Ever wondered how a small detail can make or break a guest’s experience? Let me share a story that highlights the importance of understanding what your guests need—especially when it comes to food.

A vegetarian guest booked a room with breakfast included. When they saw the standard set menu, they realized there wasn’t anything suitable for them. They asked the hotel to prepare a vegetarian option, and while the hotel agreed, they added a surcharge. The guest was hopeful, but when the meal arrived, it didn’t live up to their expectations—especially for the extra cost they paid. Even though everything else during their stay was great, this one issue stuck out, and they rated their experience 7.5/10.

This got me thinking: how did things go wrong? More importantly, what can we do to make sure this doesn’t happen again?

What Could Have Been Done Differently to Avoid Bad Ratings?

Looking back at this story, I feel the biggest issue was the lack of clear communication. If the hotel team and the guest had been on the same page from the start, this could have gone much better. Here are some simple steps that could help avoid situations like this:

1. Let Guests See the Menu in Advance

   If the guest had seen the menu earlier, they could’ve flagged the issue and worked with the staff to find a solution before breakfast. A little transparency goes a long way.

2. Talk to Guests About Their Preferences at Check-In The front desk could’ve asked about dietary preferences not just when the guest arrived but even during the booking process. Reconfirming these details at check-in ensures the information is accurate and gives the kitchen team enough time to prepare. A clear process like this makes it so much easier to meet guest expectations and create a smooth, enjoyable dining experience.

3. Create Flexible Menus

   Having a few vegetarian or vegan options on standby makes a huge difference. Use seasonal ingredients that are already available, so it doesn’t cost the hotel too much while still giving guests good-quality meals.

4. Offer a Dietary Preferences Form

   A simple checklist during booking or check-in can make things much easier for both the guest and the hotel staff. Questions like, “Do you follow a vegetarian or vegan diet?” or “Do you have any allergies?” can help the team plan ahead.

5. Be Careful with Surcharges to Avoid Bad Ratings

   Nobody likes feeling overcharged. If the request is something small, like a vegetarian meal using seasonal ingredients, it’s better not to add extra costs. Keep surcharges only for more complicated or custom requests.

A beautifully arranged assortment of vegetarian and vegan Japanese dishes highlights the importance of having diverse plant-based options readily available. Photo by: Internet

Why This Matters

When a guest feels like their needs are understood and cared for, it makes their stay so much better. On the flip side, even a small misunderstanding can leave a bad impression. By taking a little extra time to communicate and prepare, we can turn a situation like this into a win. Who doesn’t want a perfect 10/10 rating, right?

Quick Tips: Dietary Preferences and Religion

For anyone working in hospitality, understanding dietary needs tied to religion can also help avoid issues. Here’s a quick summary of common considerations with the mark "X" for excluded ingredients and "O" for included ingredients:

Religious Beliefs	Animal Products (Meat, Poultry)	Fish & Seafood	Eggs	Dairy Products	Plant-Based Foods (Proteins, Grains, Fruits & Vegetables)
Buddhism	X	X	X	X	O
Hinduism	X (beef prohibited)	X	O	O	O
Christianity (Roman Catholic)	O	O	O	O	O
Islam (Muslim)	X (pork prohibited, must be halal)	O	O	O	O

These simple notes can help staff plan meals that meet religious or cultural needs without a hitch.

A Checklist to Make Things Easier

Here’s an example of a Dietary Preferences Form that could help hotels collect dietary preferences upfront:

• Guest Name: _________________________

• Reservation Number: _______________________

• Check-In Date: _______________________

Dietary Preferences

Please answer with Yes or No to the following dietary guidelines.

1. Do you eat beef? ☐ Yes ☐ No

2. Do you eat pork? ☐ Yes ☐ No

3. Do you eat chicken? ☐ Yes ☐ No

4. Do you eat fish and seafood? ☐ Yes ☐ No

5. Do you consume dairy products (milk, cheese, yogurt)? ☐ Yes ☐ No

6. Do you eat eggs? ☐ Yes ☐ No

7. Do you follow a plant-based diet (vegetarian/vegan)? ☐ Yes ☐ No

Allergies or Special Requests

• Do you have any allergies? ☐ Yes ☐ No If yes, please list: _______________

Guest Confirmation

• Signature: _______________________

• Date: _______________________

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, it’s all about making your guests feel like they matter. Paying attention to details, especially with meals, can leave a lasting impression. A little effort in planning and communication can make all the difference. Let’s aim for happy guests and perfect ratings—because that’s what great hospitality is all about.

---

©2025 Bean JP. All Rights Reserved.